What makes a delicious soul food smothered chicken recipe? Tender, juicy chicken seasoned with soul food spices and smothered in a flavorful, creamy gravy medley. That's Southern comfort food at its finest!
Ingredients for the air fryer smothered fried chicken
6pieceschickenI used boneless chicken thighs
2tablespoonsseasoningFamous Dave’s Country Roast Chicken Seasoning (or similar)
2teaspoonsseasoningWeber Roasted Garlic & Herb Seasoning (or similar)
2cupsall-purpose flourdivided
1 ½teaspoongarlic powder
1 ½teaspoononion powder
1 ½teaspoonpaprika
¾teaspoonred pepper
1egg
½cupbuttermilk½ cup of buttermilk = ½ cup of milk & ½ tablespoon of apple cider vinegar
cooking sprayPeanut oil or vegetable oil for brushing or spraying on the chicken
Ingredients for the soul food smothered chicken gravy
1cupchicken broth
1 ½cupschicken gravyor one 12 oz. jar
¼cupheavy whipping cream
4tablespoonsflour
2teaspoonschicken bouillon
½teaspoonsalt
¼teaspoonblack pepper
¼cupparsleyOptional – chopped parsley or green onion to garnish
Instructions
Instructions for the air fried chicken
Combine the chicken seasoning and the garlic & herb seasoning in a small bowl.
Then rub the seasoning mixture onto the chicken pieces, and set the chicken aside.
Place 1 cup of the divided flour, garlic powder, onion powder, paprika, and red pepper in a medium-size mixing bowl or 1-gallon resealable food storage bag.
Shake (or mix) the sealed bag to combine the ingredients for a homemade floured poultry seasoning, and set the flour mixture aside.
Pour the second cup of flour into a second resealable bag (or medium-sized mixing bowl) and set it aside.
In another medium-sized bowl, whisk together the buttermilk and egg, and set that mixture aside too.
The chicken will go through a 3-step process from here.
First, place the chicken in the bag (or bowl) of seasoned flour and shake or toss to coat the chicken evenly.
Second, shake off the excess flour and dip the chicken into the buttermilk mixture.
Third, transfer the chicken to the last bag (or bowl) of flour and shake or toss until it’s very well coated.
Remove the chicken pieces from the bag (or bowl) and lightly brush or spray the chicken with peanut oil or vegetable oil.
If using an air fryer with a basket, spray the basket with peanut oil or vegetable oil.
Place the chicken into the air fryer, making sure it’s skin-side up. It’s okay if the chicken pieces touch; don’t overcrowd them.
Air fry at 360 degrees for a total of 20 minutes.
Halfway through, after about 10 minutes have passed, flip the chicken over in the air fryer and return to cooking.
Air fry at 360 degrees for the remaining 10 minutes or until the chicken is golden-brown and crisp all over.
Keep the chicken in the air fryer on the ‘warm’ setting until the smothered chicken gravy is ready.
Instructions for the soul food smothered chicken gravy
Add all the ingredients: chicken broth, chicken gravy, whipping cream, flour, chicken bouillon, salt, and pepper in a large pot on low (I used my Instant Pot, with the lid off on the ‘slow cook’ setting).
Whisk the ingredients to combine until the gravy mixture is lump-free and the bouillon dissolves.
Allow the mixture to heat for 3-5 minutes before it’s ready to serve with the chicken.
Serve this Black folks’ soul food smothered chicken recipe with the chicken and gravy in separate serving bowls for each dinner guest to combine on their plate. Or combine the chicken and gravy in one serving bowl.
Optionally, garnish with fresh parsley or green onion and enjoy!