Which Sweet Potato Pie Recipe Is Right For You?
This post may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you (because ya girl’s gotta eat!) View our privacy statement HERE.
Beautiful Soul, I have a confession: I don’t believe there’s only ONE right way to make sweet potato pie.

Now, don’t get me wrong. I absolutely have a favorite! My Original Black Folks Sweet Potato Pie Recipe™ is my go-to for Thanksgiving, Christmas, and just about any occasion that calls for sweet potato pie.
It’s the recipe I’ve made so many times that I practically have it committed to memory. But I also know that every family has its own idea of what sweet potato pie should taste like. Some love the familiar cinnamon-and-nutmeg flavor of Grandma’s pie. Others prefer a sweeter filling, a milder spice blend, or something a little more unexpected.
And that’s why I’ve brought my sweet potato pie recipes together in The Soul Food Pot® Sweet Potato Pie Collection. All my sweet potato pie variations, each with its own reason to be on your dessert table—Now, let’s find yours!
Which sweet potato pie should you make?
Here’s my quick guide to choosing the recipe that fits your preferences.
| If you love… | Try this sweet potato pie |
|---|---|
| My signature balance of traditional and modern Southern soul food flavors | Original Black Folks Sweet Potato Pie Recipe™ |
| A modern shortcut for preparing traditional sweet potato pie | Instant Pot-Assisted Sweet Potato Pie |
| Old-fashioned cinnamon and nutmeg without ginger | Grandma’s Sweet Potato Pie |
| A milder pie without ginger or cloves | Patti LaBelle’s Sweet Potato Pie |
| A sweeter, richer filling | Sweet Potato Pie with Condensed Milk |
| A beautiful purple holiday showstopper | Purple Sweet Potato Pie |
| Individual pies for sharing, gifting, or entertaining | Mini Sweet Potato Pies |
| A decadent cream cheese frosting | Sweet Potato Pie with Cream Cheese Frosting |
🥄 Shaunda says: You don’t need to make every variation to find the right one! Start with the flavor you love, then follow the recipe I’ve already worked out for you.

❤️ My Original Black Folks Sweet Potato Pie Recipe™: The one I make first
If you ask me which sweet potato pie to make for Thanksgiving, my answer is easy: Start with my original!
This is my signature sweet potato pie, made with evaporated milk, brown sugar, vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and cloves. The ginger and cloves are my not-so-secret-anymore secret ingredients.
They’re what give my pie that extra layer of warm, slightly sweet-peppery spice that balances the sweetness and makes the flavor stand out.

I inherited the traditional foundation of sweet potato pie from my mom. Then I developed my own flavor interpretation, bringing together the familiar Southern dessert I grew up loving with a modern twist.
The result is a pie that tastes nostalgic and distinctive at the same time. It’s sweet, but not too sweet for my palate. It’s warmly spiced without losing the natural flavor of the sweet potatoes. And it’s the version I return to again and again.
🥄 Shaunda says: If you’re making sweet potato pie for the first time, I recommend starting with my Original Black Folks Sweet Potato Pie Recipe™. Once you’ve mastered that one, you can explore the rest of the Collection!
⚡ Instant Pot-Assisted Sweet Potato Pie: My time-saving shortcut
Beautiful Soul, you know I love finding ways to make traditional soul food recipes easier without sacrificing the flavor!
My Instant Pot-assisted sweet potato pie uses the Instant Pot to cook the sweet potatoes before preparing the pie filling and baking it in the oven. That means you can enjoy the familiar flavors and creamy texture of homemade Southern sweet potato pie while simplifying one of the preparation steps.

The Instant Pot handles the sweet potatoes, but the oven still bakes the pie! It’s one of my favorite ways to bring modern kitchen convenience to a traditional Southern dessert.
👩🏾🍳 Make-It-Your-Way: If you love homemade sweet potato pie but want to streamline the preparation, this is the variation I’d recommend exploring.
🕰 Grandma’s Old-Fashioned Sweet Potato Pie: The family recipe
Before my signature ginger-and-clove twist, there was my mom’s sweet potato pie. And yes, she’s the Grandma in this story!
Her old-fashioned recipe uses cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, brown sugar, vanilla extract, and evaporated milk. No ginger.
That’s one of the defining differences between Grandma’s pie and my original recipe. Grandma’s version has the familiar warmth of cinnamon and nutmeg without the peppery lift that ginger adds to mine.
If you’re looking for an old-fashioned sweet potato pie that reminds you of the recipes passed down through Southern family kitchens, this is a beautiful place to start!
🥧 Patti LaBelle’s Sweet Potato Pie: For a milder flavor
Beautiful Soul, we’re talking about THE Miss Patti LaBelle! I’ve made her sweet potato pie recipe, adapted from the version she shares in her cookbook, and I appreciate how its flavor differs from mine.
Miss Patti’s version uses granulated sugar rather than the brown sugar I use in my signature recipe. It also leaves out ginger and cloves. That creates a milder spice profile without the warmer, more intense flavor those two spices contribute.
If you prefer sweet potato pie with a gentler seasoning profile, Miss Patti’s version may be your match. And of course, proper credit where it’s due: This is Patti LaBelle’s recipe, hunnayyy! Not my original creation.
🥛 Sweet Potato Pie with Condensed Milk: For the sweeter palate
Now, if you love a sweeter dessert, come on over here! My sweet potato pie with condensed milk is a delicious variation of my original.
The biggest difference is the milk. Instead of evaporated milk, this version uses sweetened condensed milk, which adds its own sweetness to the filling.

And yes, I use the same amount of brown sugar as in my original recipe. That means the finished pie is noticeably sweeter, although I don’t find it overwhelmingly sweet.
The filling looks and sets much like my original pie, so you’re not choosing a completely different dessert experience. You’re choosing a sweeter interpretation!
👩🏾🍳 Make-It-Your-Way: If you’re a dessert enthusiast who loves a richer, sweeter sweet potato pie, this is the variation I’d recommend exploring.
💜 Purple Sweet Potato Pie: The holiday showstopper
Want to bring something unexpected to the Thanksgiving dessert table without abandoning the sweet potato pie tradition? Make my purple sweet potato pie!
I use all-purple Stokes sweet potatoes for this recipe. The flavor is remarkably similar to traditional orange sweet potato pie, but the filling has a slightly thicker texture. And that color? Beautiful Soul, she’s a SHOWSTOPPER!
This is the pie I’d recommend when you want a familiar Southern dessert with an unforgettable presentation. It’s also my second recommendation for someone who’s already made my original recipe and wants to get a little fancy!
🎀 Mini Sweet Potato Pies: Little pies, big personality!
Who doesn’t love their own personal pie?
My mini sweet potato pies use the same filling as my Original Black Folks Sweet Potato Pie Recipe™, poured into individual mini pie crusts. So you’re getting my signature flavor in a smaller, fun-size presentation!
They’re wonderful for entertaining, gifting, sharing, and serving individual portions. They’re also easier to transport and store than a large pie.
My mini pies generally bake for approximately 30–40 minutes, but keep an eye on them because your oven may behave differently from mine. And don’t forget that mini pies still need time to cool and set!
🍰 Sweet Potato Pie with Cream Cheese Frosting: The decadent variation
And then there’s my sweet potato pie with cream cheese frosting. Because sometimes, Beautiful Soul, we want to dress dessert all the way UP!
This variation starts with the same filling as my Original Black Folks Sweet Potato Pie Recipe™. Once the pie has cooled, I spread a layer of homemade cream cheese frosting over the top.
You still get the signature sweet potato filling and warm spices, but with an additional creamy, decadent finish. So, if you love cream cheese frosting and want something a little more indulgent than a traditional sweet potato pie, this variation is for you!
Why Black folks’ sweet potato pie carries so much meaning
Sweet potato pie is more than another holiday dessert in many Black Southern families. It’s part of our culinary heritage. And that means people often have strong feelings about how it should taste.

Maybe your mama made it with evaporated milk. Maybe your grandmother didn’t use ginger. Maybe you’ve been eating the same family recipe for decades without ever knowing exactly which spices went into it.
You just know a good sweet potato pie when you taste one! That’s something I understand.
Many Beautiful Souls aren’t looking to debate every ingredient. They simply want a pie that tastes like the sweet potato pie they remember. And for someone preparing it for the first time, those family expectations can feel intimidating.
That’s one of the reasons I’ve spent so much time developing my recipes and sharing clear, step-by-step instructions. I want you to feel confident making this heritage dessert, even if I’m not physically standing beside you in your kitchen.
The tradition matters. But it shouldn’t make you afraid to bake the pie.

❤️ Why I make it this way
The technique stays consistent.
Even though my Sweet Potato Pie Collection includes different flavors and presentations, my preparation philosophy stays the same.
Cook the sweet potatoes thoroughly. Mix the filling well. And remove those pesky strings!
I use my trusted sweet potato preparation methods across the Collection, including my Instant Pot shortcut and my stand-mixer whisk technique for catching strings.
Because they work. — I said what I said!
And here’s another important lesson I’ve learned: Sweet potato pie is not always a drop-and-walk recipe.
You know I love a good kitchen shortcut, but if you’re new to baking sweet potato pie, pay attention to the oven—especially during the final 10–15 minutes of baking. Follow the instructions for the variation you’re making and watch for the recommended signs of doneness.
Once you’ve made the recipe a few times, you’ll become more familiar with how your own oven behaves.
What is the best crust for sweet potato pie?
Once you’ve chosen your sweet potato pie filling, don’t forget about the crust! A good crust complements the creamy, warmly spiced filling and gives every slice a delicious foundation.
For a homemade option, start with my Best Crust for Sweet Potato Pie recipe. It’s a helpful companion when you want to make your sweet potato pie from scratch.
Prefer a shortcut? Store-bought pie crust is another option. And if you’re serving a crowd, my Mini Sweet Potato Pies With Graham Cracker Crust use ready-made individual crusts for an easy way to serve this Southern favorite!
Why does sweet potato pie need to cool before slicing?
Because, Beautiful Soul, you’ve worked too hard to end up with a crumbled custard mess! Sweet potato pie needs time to cool and set. If you slice it too soon, the filling may not hold together the way you expect.
My general approach across the Collection is to allow at least four hours for cooling and setting, then refrigerate the pie overnight when I’m making it ahead. Cooling is part of the recipe, not an optional finishing step.
Follow the individual recipe’s instructions, especially when working with my mini pies or my frosted variation.

Can you make sweet potato pie the day before Thanksgiving?
Absolutely! In fact, this is one of my favorite ways to make Thanksgiving cooking easier. I prefer making my Thanksgiving main dishes fresh on the holiday, but desserts are my exception.
Here’s my sweet potato pie routine:
- Bake the pie according to the recipe.
- Allow it to cool and set properly on a cooling rack.
- Refrigerate it overnight.
- Serve it at room temperature or gently warmed, according to the recipe and any toppings.
And remember, if your pie has cream cheese frosting, follow its specific refrigeration and serving instructions. This way, your pie is ready before Thanksgiving Day, and your oven has one less assignment!
Should sweet potato pie be served cold?
Not at my Thanksgiving table! I enjoy sweet potato pie at room temperature or gently warmed, when its comforting spices can really shine.
In my family’s Southern soul food tradition, we don’t typically serve sweet potato pie straight from the refrigerator. But don’t confuse serving temperature with storage: pies containing eggs and dairy still need proper refrigeration after cooling.
👩🏾🍳 Make-It-Your-Way: Which pies should you bake for a crowd?
When I’m preparing sweet potato pie for a larger holiday gathering, I generally recommend two pies. And if you haven’t noticed, I always start with my original! Here are three combinations I love:
- Original + Original: When you know everybody loves the classic and you want enough to go around.
- Original + Purple: When you want my signature pie alongside a beautiful, colorful variation.
- Original + Mini Pies: When you want a traditional pie for the dessert table and individual portions guests can enjoy or take home.
You can certainly explore other combinations, but these are my go-to choices.

💡 I’ve already thought this through…
Beautiful Soul, sweet potato pie is a serious heritage dessert. It carries family memories, holiday expectations, and generations of Black Southern culinary tradition. But that doesn’t mean you have to make it exactly the way somebody else does.
I’ve created my Sweet Potato Pie Collection to give you options without making the baking process more intimidating. Start with my Original Black Folks Sweet Potato Pie Recipe™.
Then, if your family prefers a milder pie, a sweeter filling, a purple showstopper, mini portions, or a cream cheese frosting finish, there’s another recipe waiting for you!
Because the best sweet potato pie isn’t necessarily the one with the most ingredients.
It’s the one that tastes like home to YOU.
More Thanksgiving Library guides and sweet potato favorites
Found your perfect sweet potato pie? Beautiful Soul, let’s finish planning the rest of your Thanksgiving table! Explore more of my Southern holiday recipes, kitchen wisdom, and sweet potato favorites.
- How Many Thanksgiving Desserts Do You Actually Need? — Decide which Southern desserts deserve a place on your holiday table without baking every sweet treat imaginable!
- What Makes a Soul Food Thanksgiving Dinner? — Explore the family traditions, flavors, and cultural heritage behind a Southern soul food Thanksgiving.
- What Should You Serve For a Soul Food Thanksgiving Dinner? — Build your complete holiday menu, from the turkey and traditional sides to the desserts that bring everyone together.
- What Thanksgiving Sides Do You Actually Need? — Choose the soul food classics that make your Thanksgiving plate feel complete.
- Fall Classics: Southern Candied Yams That Aren’t Overly Sweet — Discover how I make tender Southern candied yams with a buttery, warmly spiced syrup that complements the sweet potatoes without overwhelming their natural flavor.
- The Soul Food Pot Candied Yams Collection — Explore my candied yams recipes and variations to find the preparation that fits your family’s holiday traditions.
- Do You Really Need a Whole Turkey for Thanksgiving? — Learn when to choose a whole roasted turkey, juicy turkey breast, wings, or legs for your Thanksgiving table.
❤️ Tap the heart at the top of this post to save it to your favorites on The Soul Food Pot!
Like this post? Pin the below image to your Pinterest “Soul Food Recipes” board!













